3-4 mins speech for the US history constitution class

My US history class has a speech to do. The class is about constitution before 1877. Everyone has a role for giving speech on some issues for NY ratification. My role is an anti-federalist. I need to speak about the ”the right of recall” of the delegate or state representatives. Write a speech about “recall” in the view of an anti-federalist. The view of Anti-federalists on “recall” must be addressed.

Recall, , serves somewhat the same purpose as rotation, but is punitive in its design and
execution. Likely recall will rarely be exercised, since the mere threat of the same should suffice to
prevent representatives from forgetting who their real masters are. Antifederalists put great store by
this power, which applies especially to upper-house senators, since their terms are so much longer
than lower-house representatives. Recommended sources are:

NYC speeches by John Lansing, June 24, Debates, pp. 294-95, 299-300, 308
NYC speech by Melancton Smith, June 25, Debates, pp. 311-15
“Federal Farmer,” XI, CA-F (2.8.147)

Surprise Argument:

The Federalist Virginia Plan presented to the Constitutional Convention included a recall (and
rotation) provision in its 4th resolution. Use again as a debating point, the purpose of which is to
embarrass. See:

Notes, May 29, p. 31

I will upload the instruction of the role. I need to do issue 6 – recall. please write the speech in the view of an anti-federalist in the convention. We are having a debate between federalists and anti federalist. The goal is to convince moderate to vote for us(anti-federalist) in the convention