Argument Analysis

Fischer writes, “Despite my
initial tendency to agree with Thomson about the original violinist case, it
seems to me that you must stay hooked up to the violinist” (280). What is
Fischer’s argument for the conclusion that, in the original version of the
violinist case, you are morally obligated to stay hooked up to the violinist?
Is his argument sound? (The Article attached below)

1. Introduction paragraph have a sophisticated thesis reveals an in-depth analysis of the
text and give appropriate background information. Innovative, original introduction that indicates writer’s
grasp of topic, purpose and audience. clearly
lay out the main things will do in the paper.

2. Body
paragraph exhibits a sophisticated and coherent structure
through skillful placement of ideas and effective transitioning.

Ideas are original,
clearly developed and supported with effective, relevant, and specific references
in order to analyze the text. 3 citations are correctly used and placed.

Utilizes terminology
appropriate to genre, chooses distinct words, and varies sentence length and
grammatical structure to create an original and confident voice both fitting to
the purpose of the essay and intended audience.

Body paragraph include:

describe Fischer’s argument for the conclusion that, in the original version of the violinist
case, you are morally obligated to stay hooked up to the violinist.

Accurately reconstruct Fischer’s
argument. Make reconstruction of the argument illuminating, helping the reader
to fully understand what the argument is?

discuss
whether Fischer’s argument is sound (make sure this discussion
thoughtful/insightful)

3. Conclusion leaving
reader satisfied and thinking. Mastery of conventions: no spelling, punctuation
or format errors